Skip to main content

Aaron Swartz

Yesterday I took part in a protest over Aaron Swartz's unjust prosecution at the hands of US attorney Carmen Ortiz. I had followed this story this winter as the details emerged of an obvious case of prosecutorial over-reach. I hope that Swartz' death will ultimately provide the impetus to reexamine some of the unbalanced priorities in the Federal judicial system, particularly the amount discretion allowed prosecutors in deciding who in this society gets treated as criminals.

Aaron Swartz used the unsecured MIT networks to download a massive amount of legal documents from the online database JSTOR and make them available on peer to peer networks. JSTOR declined to press charges, but federal prosecutors Carmen Ortiza and Stephen Haymann ultimately levied the full weight of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act against him, charging him with crimes that could have resulted in a million dollar fine and up to 35 years in jail.

Aaron Swartz' 'crime' was paying for the right to download publicly available legal documents and then making those documents available for free on the internet. This is certainly illegal, in the sense that the JSTOR prohibits this use of its documents, but let's keep in mind, these documents were made free and available to the public anyway shortly before Swartz' death.

Swartz was making a point about the access that the public should have in a democracy. In any sane system, Swartz would have been given a slap on the wrist or community service and he could have continued his remarkably promising life. After all, during the 70s, Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak were involved in the phone phreaking subculture, using technology to get long-distance phone calls for free.  When caught, no crusading prosecutor hounded them into ruin. They were given community service and went on to create Apple. The same could be said of Mark Zuckerberg. If given the same treatment as Swartz, Zuckerberg would've crashed and burned in the first 10 minutes of the 'Social Network.'

On a larger point, the legal system of the United States no longer much resembles the procedural shows on TV. We don't live in a society where 'Law and Order,' trials happen routinely. Trials are the exception.

The basic problem is that over the past thirty years there has been a steady creep of laws governing what can be considered criminal activity on the web. The way the law currently reads, any violation of a website's Terms of Service agreement can be considered a felony. That means that fake Facebook profile you created for your cat is a felony. That means the 'disrespectful' comment you left on article is a felony. The reason you never hear about people being brought up on charges on these trivial but very real crimes is that the government relies on prosecutorial discretion in who is gets arrested and charged.

But that faith in discretion is severely challenged when prosecutors like Carmen Ortiz and Stephen Haymann arbitrarily decide who will be brought up on charges, and what they will be charged with. The whole notion of innocent until proved guilty is rendered meaningless when the state coerce confessions with ridiculously severe penalties for the most trivial crime.
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Review of I Wish I Was Like You by S.P. Miskowski

Even 23 years later, I remember 1994 and Kurt Cobain's death. I experienced that moment as a kind of inside out personal crisis. I felt ashamed by his death. As though his exit in someway indicted my own teenage miseries. "I wish I was like you," goes the verse in 'All Apologies,' "Easily amused." I felt as though a check I hadn't remembered writing had just been cashed. 

SP Miskowski's book, named after the first half of that line, is in the words of another reviewer, a novel that shouldn't work. The narrator is unlikeable, unreliable, and dead. The plot is almost entirely told as a flashback and long sections of the novel concern the inner processes of the writer. The daily grind to summon up enough self-esteem to carry a sentence to its logical conclusion is a real struggle, people, but it ain't exactly riveting.

But the thing is, this novel works. It is one of the best things I've read all year and a real achievement in weird ficti…

What I Read in 2017

The third in my series of year-end lists is literature. As in past years, I've divided this post into two categories: Novels and short stories. Each of these stories made 2017 just a bit brighter for me and I hope this list includes at least a writer or two new to you.

I Wish I was You by SP Miskowski: This was the subject of a review earlier this year. The way I feel about this novel, the tragedy of a talented person crippled by anger and regret, transformed into a monstrous avatar of wrath, has not really left me. Beyond the perfection of its prose and its preternatural subject matter, I feel like this is one of the best evocations of the mid-nineties I've seen published. There's something about this book that lingers with me long past the concerns of its plot and characters. I guess what I'm trying to say is this work moved me. 2017 would have been a lot dimmer if I hadn't read this work.New York 2140 by Kim Stanley Robinson: Robinson writes next-level sp…

Review of "Pretty Marys All in a Row" by Gwendolyn Kiste

Part of the reason American Gods works is that it offers a kind of reward to folk lore mavens and religious study majors. Do you have a working familiarity with obscure Northern European mythologies? Are you able to describe what Neil Gaiman got right and what he fudged a bit in terms of the Egyptian religion? Then the guessing games of that novel - just which Middle Eastern Goddess is this? - magnify its other charms. 
"Pretty Marys All in a Row" by Gwendolyn Kiste (released by Broken Eye Books), is a novella for people, like me, who are waiting impatiently for the next season of Bryan Fuller's show. It's not set in that universe, certainly, but approaches the question of folklore from a similar perspective. Namely, that myths have a definite, physical explanation and your knowledge of such things will expand your enjoyment of the work. In the case of Pretty Marys, the stories are urban legends and nursery rhymes about young women. The main character, Rhee, is named…