Skip to main content

Review of "Ghost in the Shell"

I saw "Ghost in the Shell," on Friday and overall I think I'd recommend it. There are plenty of cyberpunk or influence-by-cyberpunk movies coming out this year but I think this will carve out its own distinct niche: stylish, garishly beautiful in places but ultimately middling science fiction.


Things I liked: the action scenes are very cool, sharply executed, and kinetic. It gave me the impression that the director Rupert Sanders has spent some quality time watching the first John Wick movie, which I mean as a compliment. The version of the future here is neon-drenched and weird, with enormous holograms peeking out from behind sky-scrapers kaiju style. The streets crawl with criminal low-lives, augmented with ghastly prosthetics and weaponry, and everything is sort of splashed on the screen without exposition. For some one raised on Ghost in the Shell, Akira, and Neuromancer the effect was strangely comforting - ah, here's the future I was promised! - but I could also imagine someone else being frustrated by the movie's approach. A larger issue is the 'white-washing' controversy. Unfortunately talking about this in any detail is going to get into SPOILER territory.

So, SPOILERS!!!

In the manga and subsequent anime, the main character Motoko "Major" Kusanagi is depicted as Japanese. So, is casting Scarlett Johansson an act of cultural appropriation? Having seen the film, I would say it's a bit complicated but the way the movie addresses the issue does represent a real missed opportunity. While the synthetic body that Motoko uses is caucasian, it is revealed later on that that body is a 'shell' for her true identity. Her original, natural identity was Japanese but her ghost was placed into a caucasian body. Nothing more is made of this other than Motoko's pre-prosthetic existence was considerably richer and more detailed than her spartan, narrow life in the movie. 

A smarter, more daring movie would have made a point of exploring this. Why is the default model of prosthesis white? Could this movie even draw a parallel between how the mainstream in our own society is often narrowly defined as being 'white?' so much so that a caucasian actress is cast in a role very specifically written as Japanese in comics, television shows, and movies? The more I think about it, the more cynical this ploy feels - just because Motoko becomes white because of the company that built her wanted her that way doesn't really bring into question why the director and the various production companies made exactly the same choice in bringing the source material to a (larger) Western audience.

This lack of daring also extends to my basic impression of the movie's theme. Where are the big risks? This movie acts as a shadow play of the original movie, performing the big set-piece scenes and updating the special effects without really understanding what those scenes mean. Borrowing insight from a Youtube video about the necessity of "Return of the King's" many endings, a story really has two types of endings: the plot ending and the thematic ending. In the plot ending, the sources of conflict are resolved. The main villain is defeated, the estranged mother and daughter are reconciled, and the forgetful fish finds her true parents. But stories also have thematic endings: the point in a story in which the overall meaning of the story is fixed into place. 

In both the original GitS anime movie and this current version, the plot ends in a climatic battle with a 'spiderbot,' a bad-assed piece of military technology intent on killing Motoko. With great sacrifice, Motoko prevails. Cue credits. Now, to give the current movie its due, this set-piece is executed with aplomb and is pretty entertaining. But that's all ultimately it is. 

The original also included a long monologue about the nature of consciousness and the importance of evolution that ended up convincing Motoko to join the "Puppetmaster" (as the antagonist in the original was named) in uploading to cyberspace, fusing together in a new hybrid existence. Powerful stuff that both elaborated upon the themes of machines and humanity merging and complicated it by suggesting that perhaps Motoko was never really that different from a machine in the first place.

Where is the effort to introduce something new? To explore some new corner of cybernetic philosophy or perhaps question more completely what it means to live in a world where memories can be erased and replaced at will? Maybe that's a lot to ask from a Hollywood action flick but it is precisely this that the original delivered twenty-two years ago.

Anyway, the best thing I can say about this movie is it was entertaining and while I sincerely hope it is not the best sci fi movie released this year, it's worth a watch.
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Solemn Treasures

In Gilead, the transcendent novel by Marilynn Robinson, a 76 year old man confronts his impending mortality and the sense he cannot provide for his young son after he is gone. He had not expected to meet his son's mother in the twilight of his life, not expected to have a son. If he had, he tells his son in a lengthy letter forming the substance of Robinson's novel, he might have set something by for him. Some sort of savings or investment. It pains him to think that when he is gone, all that he can leave are a few words.

What words.

As mentioned in a previous post, I set myself on the task (is that really the right word here? maybe endeavor would be better) to read as many of the 'great novels' of this young century as I could. After reading Hillary Mantel's "Wolf Hall-" which was also fantastic by the way - I made my way to Gilead. One of the many quietly strange things about this novel is that it's actually the second novel from Robinson. Her first…

New Story Acceptance!

As mentioned last week, I do have a bit of happy news to share. I am excited to announce that my story, "The Yuru-chara of Hector, NY," will appear in the next issue of the Electric Spec Magazine at the end of the month. I am tremendously excited about this for a few reasons:
Electric Spec is simply awesome. I've been reading this magazine for awhile and never been disappointed by a single story. To have one of my stories selected is beyond humbling. I can only give an earnest thank you to Lesley L. Smith for choosing the story.I love this story dearly. It has one of my favorite protagonists and shows in the clearest way I've managed where I'd like to go with my fiction. Electric Spec also gave me the chance to reflect on this story and its meaning in a guest blog which I am sharing below. Without being spoilery, this blog expresses some of what resonates about "The Yuru-chara of Hector, NY," with me. Guest Blog at Electric SpecAt the moment, I think the…

"The Yuru-chara of Hector, NY" is now available!

My new story, "The Yuru-chara of Hector, NY," is now available in the current issue of the Electric Spec magazine. I'm very proud that this story is getting published at Electic Spec for the simple reason I've been reading the magazine for years, dreaming of the day I might get a story published there. Well, it's finally happened.

The story of "Yuru-chara" is pretty simple: a young girl wakes up to discover that her old virtual friend, a seven-foot-tall yellow monster named Tama Bell, has come to life. While navigating through waves of other virtual creatures released through a world-wide hack, the young heroine tries to come to grips with her responsibility to her forgotten friend and the losses inherent to growing up.

I hope that you enjoy my story and that you give the other stories a try. They're awesome!

Thank you for your continued support.